Boot questions

[Janie Grace]

I want a pair of short boots to wear with knee-length sweater dresses and leggings. I think this is going to be my "winter uniform." (I hate jeans.) 

 

Would you wear a pair of brown boots with black leggings? What shade do you think is them most versatile? I have a pair of black and a pair of brown knee-high boots already, but I want short boots (booties). Sometimes I just don't feel like having my calves all wrapped up. :)

 

What do you think of lace-up boots with this ensemble? (See link below.) I actually like the look more than the really wide booties that are so popular... I think lace-ups look more old-fashioned/classic and I like how they are flush with the leg rather than gapping. But I don't trust my judgment and I need someone to tell me if they are going to look ridiculous.

If I get the more common booties, I will probably get a pair like the second link. 

 

http://www.zappos.com/rockport-cobb-hill-carrie-black

 

http://www.zappos.com/dolce-vita-sutton-anthracite-suede

 

Please advise!

 

 

Edited October 22, 2016 by Janie Grace

[gardenmom5]

I would not mix black and brown.

 

cordovan . .

 

I would find black boots more useful - but I wouldn't wear them with brown.  a brown plaid that also had black in it would be okay.

 

eta: I don't see the point of what look like combat boots being worn as casual shoes.  I wouldn't be wearing suede outside in the winter.

Edited October 22, 2016 by gardenmom5

[Happy]

I like the suede boot better, but then, I've never cared for the lace up type. I think the overall shape of the suede boot would look good with a sweater dress and leggings.

 

Black is pretty versatile to me. Mixing brown and black can be done--think equestrian outfit looks--but it's gotta be done right. For that reason, I usually don't try. :)

 

 

[marbel]

I also prefer not to mix black and brown.  Black leggings = black shoes, imo.    Brown leggings I think could go with either black or brown boots.  That's my preference, not making a statement on what is correct style.  

 

I do like the look of both boots.  My daughter wears combat style boots with everything and I think it's a good look.   Like you, I prefer the close-fitting boot with dresses/skirts

 

Here in the Mid-Atlantic,I would not wear suede.   If it is not wet/snowy where you live, then...  

[bibiche]

You can definitely mix brown and black *if* you do it with style. Otherwise you might look like you have made a mistake. You can do something as simple as making your scarf (or bag, or belt) animal print to bring the colors together.

 

Boots are a very personal thing. ;). I would prefer a full-on military look ( think Docs) to the feminized lace up boot. The second boot I myself wouldn't choose because it is suede and a little low. But why not wear whatever your preferred uniform is to a shoe store and try on different types of boots to get an idea of what works for you and your look?

Edited October 22, 2016 by bibiche

[Cecropia]

You can have the best of both worlds by choosing a true black boot with a contrasting brown sole.  (I can't tell if your second link with "anthracite" is blackish or brownish, looks more brown to me)

Example [edit, this link goes to the grey automatically, choose black to see what I mean]

http://www.zappos.com/lucky-brand-gulvan-storm?zlfid=191&ref=pd_detail_4_sims_v

This way you can match either brown or black leggings.

Edited October 22, 2016 by Cecropia

[bibiche]

i find that it is nearly always best to go with leggings that are the same color as the boot to keep a good line. If you have mile long fabulous legs it might not apply, but generally, not chopping off the feet is a good rule.

[wendy not in HI]

I just bought two pairs of booties for the fall.  One in a grey suede similar to your link.  I think brown and black is actually in this year.  Look at men - they are wearing brown shoes with black or grey suits.  My girls have a couple pairs of the tighter lace up boots, but a little more feminine than the one you linked and they wear them with skirts.  One dd has a pair of lace up boots with a bit of flannel on the top fold down flap - so cute!  Anyway, I think booties are adorable.  I say go for it.  You can mix and match with leggings and skirts.  You can add in some chunky socks if you need to break up the brown with black...