Jump to content

Menu

Favorite INEXPENSIVE writing curriculum for middle school? and what was your LEAST fav.


rawbanana
 Share

Recommended Posts

We tried Writing Strands and didn't like it (we are doing My Father's World)...I have Wordsmith Apprentice that I got free so I'm going to try that next. My girls I'm using this for are almost 14 and 12. 

Telling  me what you like and why you like it

OR

what you DIDNT like =)

 

I'm on a very tight budget-keep that in mind! =)

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I use the suggestions in  SWB's Writing in the Middle Grades audio; very inexpensive, and easy to adapt to whatever books you have on hand (she advocates writing across the curriculum). 

 

The sample for Writing with Skill ( "samples" tab in the Peace Hill Press store) is very meaty...166 pages of goodness to eyeball and work through...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Writing Strands. Sorry. :-) I love the way it teaches. My only regret is that we didn't get to use all levels, because my dc were almost into community college by the time they were all published; if I were hsing again, I would do everything I could to do all the levels.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Writing Strands. Sorry. :-) I love the way it teaches. My only regret is that we didn't get to use all levels, because my dc were almost into community college by the time they were all published; if I were hsing again, I would do everything I could to do all the levels.

 

My daughter was bored silly with this one. Sorry. ;-D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Write with the Best volume 1 and 2

Hewitt lightening literature and composition (Don't buy the vocabulary unless you feel the child doesn't read much. IMO it's not necessary for students who read often and varied materials.)

NaNoWriMo has a free middle school lesson plan that would cover a semester with a bit of adding here and there.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree with Essentials in Writing for an inexpensive and solid middle school writing program.

How limited are your resources? Essentials in writing if fairly cheap and seems good. Could you combine your kids on one level do you think?

 

If not you would need to get two levels although you would only have to do that for a year or two as you can reuse the DVD and reprint the workbooks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Essentials in Writing. I tried everything else and this one is finally clicking for my older boys AND my younger lkids like it, too.

 

LEAST FAVORITE: everything else: IEW, WWE/WWS, CC, CW, WS, Jump In!, WWW, CAP, Logos...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We used The Lively Art of Writing (Mentor Series) by Lucile Vaughan Payne in 8th grade.  At $6.99, the price is hard to beat!

 

I was going to suggest this. A friend got it via Paperback Swap for me.

 

Also, if you can work off the computer screen, you can work through William Henry Maxwell's vintage writing books - School Composition, followed by Writing in English.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We did try Writing Strands level 2 and 3 and nobody cared for them, so that's why I was looking for something a little different. HOWEVER, my friend IS going to loan me WS level 4 just so I can look at it =)

 

Oh, I never recommend Level 2.

 

And it's possible that none of the kidlets will like anything, so there you go. :-)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Crisis Composition Plan

 

3 Sentence Report

3 Paragraph Report

5 Paragraph Essay/Report

5 Paragraph Persuasive Essay/Report

 

The Handwritten Letter

 

Picture Study

 

Story Writing

 

Book Reports

 

Poetry Writing

 

Mechanics

 

Vocabulary

 

***********************************

 

Read the Write On! Teacher Manual for general writing advice

http://www.learn4yourlife.com/support-files/writeoninstructorsguide.pdf

 

The 3 Sentence Report

2nd to last page of this pdf

http://www.learn4yourlife.com/support-files/writeoninstructorsguide.pdf

Introduce Bing, Bang and Bongo. Do not introduce the bananas or barrel yet.

Use the Brainstorm Graphic Organizer, Cutouts

http://www.csun.edu/~sspencer/documents/InteractiveWrtgPt2.pdf

Video introduction of Bing Bang Bongo. Bing=blue, Bang=red, Bongo=green.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=laxW-tTG_6k

 

The 3 Paragraph Report/Essay

The last page of this pdf

http://www.learn4yourlife.com/support-files/writeoninstructorsguide.pdf

Continue using Bing, Bang and Bongo. Do a 3 paragraph Favorite Things Essay. Cut the banana and barrel sections off of any worksheets used.

http://www.csun.edu/~sspencer/documents/InteractiveWrtgPt2.pdf

Research Gathering Grid. Fold up a large piece of art paper, or tape together several pieces of paper.

http://questgarden.com/139/61/3/120608222628/files/gathering%20grid.pdf

MLA Bibliography Guide

http://www.edu.pe.ca/gulfshore/PDFs/bibform.pdf

 

5 Paragraph Report/Essay

Introduce the Bing, Bang. Bongo bananas and barrel paragraphs.

http://www.csun.edu/~sspencer/documents/InteractiveWrtgPt2.pdf

Rewatch video introduction of Bing Bang Bongo, and retain these colors. Into=yellow, Bing=blue, Bang=red, Bongo=green, conclusion=purple.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=laxW-tTG_6k

More advanced video. Do not use these colors. 

Practice writing essays with introductions and conclusions, while just outlining the body paragraphs. See Write On! worksheet 37.

http://web.archive.org/web/20100209045138/http://www.kid-friendly-homeschool-curriculum.com/Homeschool-writing-contest.html

Introduction Worksheet

http://jimmiescollage.com/downloads/writing/introduction-paragraph-graphic-organizer.pdf

Conclusion Worksheet

http://jimmiescollage.com/downloads/writing/conclusion-paragraph-graphic-organizer.pdf

5 Paragraph Report

Bing Bang Bongo: Use Research Outline Page, Dinosaur Model Essay, and Research Gathering Grid from above.

http://www.csun.edu/~sspencer/documents/InteractiveWrtgPt4.pdf

 

Writing an Effective Title

http://writing.umn.edu/sws/assets/pdf/quicktips/titles.pdf

How to Capitalize Titles

http://www.santarosa.edu/~kthornle/30/CapitalizationMLAStyle.pdf

 

A Simple Topic Sentence=Topic + Main Point.

Six Ways to Form a Topic Sentence

http://content.bfwpub.com/webroot_pubcontent/Content/BCS_5/Stepping%20Stones%202e/Student%20Resources/Six%20Ways%20to%20Form%20a%20Topic%20Sentence.pdf

 

These composition lessons in Harvey's Grammar can be used with the above methods. Animals: 40, 59. Plants and products: 82, 99, 105. Metals and elements: 112, 116. Disasters and phenomena of nature: 120.

http://books.google.com/books?id=hB8BAAAAYAAJ&dq=harvey

 

5 Paragraph Persuasive Essay/Report

Bing, Bang Bongo Persuasive Essay

http://www.csun.edu/~sspencer/documents/InteractiveWrtgPt5.pdf

A Simple Thesis=Topic sentence that states an opinion.

Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wCzuAMVmIZ8

Writing Thesis Statements in 3 Steps

http://campuses.fortbendisd.com/campuses/documents/Teacher/2013%5Cteacher_20130115_1634.pdf

 

The Handwritten Letter

http://www.nhcs.net/parsley/curriculum/postal/FriendlyLetter.html

Address envelopes in all caps and no punctuation. Double spaces replace punctuation. Very Important new changes!

http://data.grammarbook.com/blog/numbers/how-do-i-write-addresses/

 

Writing About a Picture pgs. 6-9

http://books.google.com/books?id=0vUAAAAAYAAJ&printsec=frontcover#v=onepage&q&f=false

 

Story Writing 

Write Your Own Story with a Cinderella Plot

http://data.grammarbook.com/blog/numbers/how-do-i-write-addresses/

How to Write Your Own Scary Story

http://www.readwritethink.org/files/resources/lesson_images/lesson407/write-scary2.pdf

 

Book Reports

http://www.lovetolearnplace.com/BookReports/BookReport.html

 

25 Types of Poetry

http://www.teacherspayteachers.com/Product/25-Types-of-Poetry-123703

or

http://myteacherpages.com/webpages/jgriffin/files/25%20Types%20of%20Poetry.pdf

 

Mechanics

Capitalization and Punctuation Rules

http://www.sanchezclass.com/capitalization-punctuation.htm#A

Sentence Patterns

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-FbXcqs6Felo/UGtL4076qlI/AAAAAAAACOM/fsH9zD3cmAQ/s1600/sentencepatternswebpic.jpg

Daily Grammar

http://dailygrammar.com/archive.html

 

Banishing Boring Words

http://www.sbcusd.k12.ca.us/DocumentCenter/View/117175

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

By the way, I found handouts by a teacher from Oklahoma named Mrs. Ayn Grubb who has done some presentations on Killgallon. They provide a nice overview of the method and how she implements this style in her own classroom -- including having her students look for interesting sentences

 

http://www.mrsgrubb.com/PDFfiles/APSI/TCU2012/2012.RealLangRealGram.pdf

http://www.mrsgrubb.com/PDFfiles/APSI/TCU2012/2012.GramKillgallon.pdf

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My dd did wordsmith apprentice as a 10 yr old (she is not an advanced writer), so I would look for something more for your kids. I think middle school is time to hit grammar and structure. You could have them both do an IEW theme book, and a strong grammar program (like Analytical Grammar, MCT, or Hake), sharing materials.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Are you working off the computer, or did you buy a printed copy of the book?

 

I printed it and made it into 5 booklets based on what was being studied -- sentence, paragraph, narration, description, etc. 

 

In the program, you study great writers, outline their work, and then try to mimick it.  Here is an example of a classic and my son's mimic.

 

 By Washington Irving

As we drove into the great gateway of the inn, I saw on one side the

light of a rousing kitchen fire beaming through a window. I entered

and admired, for the hundredth time, that picture of convenience,

neatness, and broad honest enjoyment, the kitchen of an English inn.

It was of spacious dimensions, hung round with copper and tin vessels

highly polished, and decorated here and there with a Christmas green.

Hams, tongues, and flitches of bacon were suspended from the

ceiling;a smoke jack made its ceaseless clanking beside the fire-

place, and a clock ticked in one corner. A well-scoured deal table

extended along one side of the kitchen, with a cold round of beef and

other hearty viands upon it, over which two foaming tankards of ale

seemed mounting guard. Travelers of inferior order were preparing to

attack this stout repast, while others sat smoking and gossiping over

their ale on two high-backed oaken Fettles beside the fire. Trim

housemaids were hurrying backward and forward under the directions of

a fresh, bustling landlady; but still seizing an occasional moment to

exchange a flippant word and have a rallying laugh with the group

round the fire.

 

 

As I walked into the Hufflepuff common room, I saw a large ornate fire place on one side giving the room a warm and cosy feel.  I thought for the hundredth time that who ever designed this comfortable, relaxing place must have been a genius.  The walls were of a deep mahogany polished over centuries to a lustrous sheen.  Hanging gracefully over diamond paned windows, gold velvet curtains, embroidered richly with gold thread and decorated with long tassels, fell to the floor.  Illuminating the room, several candles, filled with unwavering magical flame, hung from the ceiling; a painting of Helga Hufflepuff whispered ceaselessly to its self, and a grandfather clock ticked in one corner.  A number of plush chairs were clustered round a low table set with strawberry tarts and coconut pastries over which several bottles of butter bear stood like watchful outposts over the rest of the meal.  Students back from the quiditch game were celebrating loudly over this stout repast, while others were studying ineffectively in a cold corner.  Several black cats were scuffling under the table while owners were desperately trying to separate them, but the felines still had enough time for a strong paw and a playful slap.

 

+++++

 

If you look closely, he has copied Irving sentence by sentence.  My ds has a great vocabulary on his own, but the style of this piece he wrote is all Irving.  I think it is a great way to learn how to write; many programs use this approach but this is the best free one out there IMHO.  There is also the one before this one called School Composition, which has easier work to study and mimic.  We chose the harder one because my ds liked the passages better and I thought he would be more motivated.  We just do it very slowly.

 

Ruth in NZ

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I printed it and made it into 5 booklets based on what was being studied -- sentence, paragraph, narration, description, etc. 

 

In the program, you study great writers, outline their work, and then try to mimick it.  Here is an example of a classic and my son's mimic.

...

 

If you look closely, he has copied Irving sentence by sentence.  My ds has a great vocabulary on his own, but the style of this piece he wrote is all Irving.  I think it is a great way to learn how to write; many programs use this approach but this is the best free one out there IMHO.  There is also the one before this one called School Composition, which has easier work to study and mimic.  We chose the harder one because my ds liked the passages better and I thought he would be more motivated.  We just do it very slowly.

 

Ruth in NZ

 

Thank you. His imitation is wonderful. I'll be thrilled when my dd will start writing like that. :)

You are right that Maxwell's books are the best free approaches to writing by imitation.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was going to suggest this. A friend got it via Paperback Swap for me.

 

Also, if you can work off the computer screen, you can work through William Henry Maxwell's vintage writing books - School Composition, followed by Writing in English.

 

 

I really like these!  I have printed "Progressive Composition" Book 2 for this year, but I like these too-- 

 

We also have a couple of "Imitation in Writing" books and Jump In--so many good options, but these look fabulous--

 

What age/grade do you think they are for?  I'm a terrible judge of that--

 

B--

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was going to suggest this. A friend got it via Paperback Swap for me.

 

Also, if you can work off the computer screen, you can work through William Henry Maxwell's vintage writing books - School Composition, followed by Writing in English.

 

 

I really like these!  I have printed "Progressive Composition" Book 2 for this year, but I like these too-- 

 

We also have a couple of "Imitation in Writing" books and Jump In--so many good options, but these look fabulous--

 

What age/grade do you think they are for?  I'm a terrible judge of that--

 

B--

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Writing in English is supposed to be a high school book, but I am using it with a 5th grader.  We just go slowly and we work through the paragraphs together.  There is no way he could do the book independently although a high schooler could.  I asked him to outline one of the paragraphs yesterday, and there was just no way.  But if I talk him through it, he understands.  So I use the curriculum more as a jumping off point to start discussions and to celebrate language.  Who couldn't love Irving's description that I posted above?  It is just delicious.

 

Ruth in NZ

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Writing in English is supposed to be a high school book..

 

And School Composition is for "the higher grammar grades", so I assume it was meant for gr 7-8. But there are moms here who use(d) it with their gr 5-6 dc.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We used The Lively Art of Writing (Mentor Series) by Lucile Vaughan Payne in 8th grade.  At $6.99, the price is hard to beat!

 

Regards,

Kareni

 

I have Lively Art of Writing, and what I have previewed looks very good and doable. 

 

I also have Hands-On Essays, which we will be going through quickly.  I have not listened to the free video lectures online, but the book is very clear and should be easy/painless to get through I think.

 

http://www.handsonessays.com/

 

ETA:  My natural writer did not enjoy WWS level 1 at all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I used Scholastic books for the types of writing and specific writing content needs, at a dollar they are cheap and do good.  Previously, we used Remedia Publications workbooks - love these too.

 

I use the Write Source books for correct grade level with the Hewitt syllabus, which would include the TM and Skills Practice for each of the handbooks.

 

As well, I switched to Stobaugh for history and literature.  I did this primarily for the weekly writing and critical thinking.  They are applicable to skill sets needed for college-bound students.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Writing in English is supposed to be a high school book, but I am using it with a 5th grader.  We just go slowly and we work through the paragraphs together.  There is no way he could do the book independently although a high schooler could.  I asked him to outline one of the paragraphs yesterday, and there was just no way.  But if I talk him through it, he understands.  So I use the curriculum more as a jumping off point to start discussions and to celebrate language.  Who couldn't love Irving's description that I posted above?  It is just delicious.

 

Ruth in NZ

 

 

And School Composition is for "the higher grammar grades", so I assume it was meant for gr 7-8. But there are moms here who use(d) it with their gr 5-6 dc.

 

Thanks!

 

B

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I printed it and made it into 5 booklets based on what was being studied -- sentence, paragraph, narration, description, etc. 

 

In the program, you study great writers, outline their work, and then try to mimick it.  Here is an example of a classic and my son's mimic.

 

 By Washington Irving

As we drove into the great gateway of the inn, I saw on one side the

light of a rousing kitchen fire beaming through a window. I entered

and admired, for the hundredth time, that picture of convenience,

neatness, and broad honest enjoyment, the kitchen of an English inn.

It was of spacious dimensions, hung round with copper and tin vessels

highly polished, and decorated here and there with a Christmas green.

Hams, tongues, and flitches of bacon were suspended from the

ceiling;a smoke jack made its ceaseless clanking beside the fire-

place, and a clock ticked in one corner. A well-scoured deal table

extended along one side of the kitchen, with a cold round of beef and

other hearty viands upon it, over which two foaming tankards of ale

seemed mounting guard. Travelers of inferior order were preparing to

attack this stout repast, while others sat smoking and gossiping over

their ale on two high-backed oaken Fettles beside the fire. Trim

housemaids were hurrying backward and forward under the directions of

a fresh, bustling landlady; but still seizing an occasional moment to

exchange a flippant word and have a rallying laugh with the group

round the fire.

 

 

As I walked into the Hufflepuff common room, I saw a large ornate fire place on one side giving the room a warm and cosy feel.  I thought for the hundredth time that who ever designed this comfortable, relaxing place must have been a genius.  The walls were of a deep mahogany polished over centuries to a lustrous sheen.  Hanging gracefully over diamond paned windows, gold velvet curtains, embroidered richly with gold thread and decorated with long tassels, fell to the floor.  Illuminating the room, several candles, filled with unwavering magical flame, hung from the ceiling; a painting of Helga Hufflepuff whispered ceaselessly to its self, and a grandfather clock ticked in one corner.  A number of plush chairs were clustered round a low table set with strawberry tarts and coconut pastries over which several bottles of butter bear stood like watchful outposts over the rest of the meal.  Students back from the quiditch game were celebrating loudly over this stout repast, while others were studying ineffectively in a cold corner.  Several black cats were scuffling under the table while owners were desperately trying to separate them, but the felines still had enough time for a strong paw and a playful slap.

 

+++++

 

If you look closely, he has copied Irving sentence by sentence.  My ds has a great vocabulary on his own, but the style of this piece he wrote is all Irving.  I think it is a great way to learn how to write; many programs use this approach but this is the best free one out there IMHO.  There is also the one before this one called School Composition, which has easier work to study and mimic.  We chose the harder one because my ds liked the passages better and I thought he would be more motivated.  We just do it very slowly.

 

Ruth in NZ

 

I loved your son's paragraph. I especially loved the black cats for the housemaids. Wonderful imitation work. Thank you for sharing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Just thought I would update everyone.  We started school on 8/25.  My reluctant non-fiction writing DD LOVES her writing this year - Jump In.  She is thrilled with it and says she feels like the author understands her and is talking directly to her.  Right now it's her favorite class.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We've done IEW (SWI A, continuation A, and Bible), EIW, and Worksmith Apprentice over the past few years. For cheap - search the boards for Lively Art of Writing. Some insanely amazing kind soul made a workbook and TM, which you can print - for free. We're using it now and it's wonderful. For the others - IEW was $$$ but excellent. EIW was too easy (one paragraph a day - outlined - for 7th grade?), and WA was a lot of fun but again, my kids thought it was too easy. I'm not sure they retained much. HTH

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just thought I would update everyone.  We started school on 8/25.  My reluctant non-fiction writing DD LOVES her writing this year - Jump In.  She is thrilled with it and says she feels like the author understands her and is talking directly to her.  Right now it's her favorite class.

 

Thanks for updating! I always think it's nice when people come back to a thread and report what they picked and how it went.  It's super helpful for future searchers, too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Understanding Writing by Susan Bradrick.  It's $75, but it would cover all of your dc from grades 1-12.

 

 

You can find it used for much cheaper, by the way. Check ebay and homeschool classifieds.

 

Sometimes Exodus Books sells it used for about $25.00. It looks like they don't have any copies right now, but it's worth it to keep checking.

 

http://www.exodusbooks.com/details.aspx?id=6341

 

It's a good curriculum. I used most of level 1 and 2, and bits of the other levels, before I got distracted.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...