11 replies to this topic
#1
Posted 13 May 2013  12:07 PM
I am using Saxon Math 3 this year with my two daughters in 3rd grade. It uses skip counting. They grasp the concept, but take forever to figure out the multiplication answers. They also make mistakes when skip counting, if they count by themselves and then get answers wrong based on the wrong counting. I am wondering what other people do to teach this nowadays? Thanks in advance.
#2
Posted 13 May 2013  12:08 PM
We use both skip counting and memorization. Both skills are useful.
#3
Posted 13 May 2013  12:16 PM
They grasp the concept, but take forever to figure out the multiplication answers. They also make mistakes when skip counting, if they count by themselves and then get answers wrong based on the wrong counting.
Those are the same two reasons why I abandoned skip counting and moved towards drilling strategies for multiplication facts.
#4
Posted 13 May 2013  12:34 PM
We use skip counting long enough to understand the concept. Then memorize the facts. Division is easier if you know your multiplication facts.
#5
Posted 13 May 2013  01:37 PM
We drill multiplication facts after the child has a good understanding of what multiplication is. Before the facts are solidly memorized, we use serial addition to find the answer to a problem.
#6
Posted 13 May 2013  02:12 PM
Saxon uses both; they start with skip counting but definitely cover math facts as well. Saxon almost goes overboard IMHO in the amount of addition and multiplication fact drills they do.
#7
Posted 13 May 2013  03:15 PM
I agree that memorizing multiplication facts is the way to go. But, they do also need to know how to do basic skip counting (2s, 5s, 10s) and that can help with math as well. I remember memorizing all of my multiplication facts (up to 12) when I was in 3rd grade.
#8
Posted 13 May 2013  03:39 PM
We do both. I was taught with just skip counting, my dh was drilled. I found both to be a little lacking. We start with skip counting, which gives them a solid understanding of what they are doing with multiplication. Then once they are comfortable with skip counting with all the basics (2,3,4,5,7, and 10 forwards and backwards), then we start drills with the multiplication facts. I'm finding my kids are very comfortable playing with numbers.
#9
Posted 13 May 2013  05:18 PM
Another vote for both. I use skip counting to intro, then follow up with memorization/drill.
Saxon starts skip counting in K, so normally a third grader in Saxon would have been doing skip counting a long time and be ready to memorize.
Saxon starts skip counting in K, so normally a third grader in Saxon would have been doing skip counting a long time and be ready to memorize.
#10
Posted 13 May 2013  05:53 PM
Both. Skip counting makes sense for some of the numbers, but for others I think it is more tedious.
#11
Posted 13 May 2013  06:22 PM
I thought skip counting was to understand the concept better and then memorization kicks in.
#12
Posted 13 May 2013  07:13 PM
I will do both plus show the concept with manipulatives. We already are working on skip counting in kindergarten. She knows her 2s, 5s, 10s and 25s to 100. I plan on eventually showing the concept with cuisenaire rods and working more with skip counting relating to multiplication. Once they really understand what multiplication is I wouldn't mind them memorizing it.
Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: math
Education →
K8 Curriculum Board →
Any Art of Problem Solving Prealgebra users?Started by Natalia , Yesterday, 12:28 PM math, art of problem solving and 1 more... 



Education →
Accelerated Learner Board →
News: First female winner for Fields maths medalStarted by Arcadia , 13 Aug 2014 fields medal, math, geometry 



Education →
K8 Curriculum Board →
RS Math & TT, do I have to supplement with Word Problems?Started by OrganicMom , 11 Aug 2014 math, tt, rsm, wordproblems 



Education →
Accelerated Learner Board →
Dover mathematics series and Math GirlsStarted by klwalukas , 09 Aug 2014 dover, math girls 



Education →
K8 Curriculum Board →
Horizons Math 6 to Chalkdust Algebra 1?Started by JubilantNest , 04 Aug 2014 horizons, math, prealgebra and 1 more... 

